Well cooked, well managed Huge portions of well cooked Greek and eclectic diner fare. Friendly, efficient waitresses and managers. The gyros have enough lamb... read moreHuge portions of well cooked Greek and eclectic diner fare. Friendly, efficient waitresses and managers. The gyros have enough lamb for 3 people. You must order extra pita to make more wraps. Excellent breakfasts. The bacon is crisp, the rolls fresh, the eggs perfectly prepared. Altogether a big asset for Wading River. read less

Good food I like this place because they will make you just about anything you want. I have a picky diet so... read moreI like this place because they will make you just about anything you want. I have a picky diet so the waiter got my order exactly how I wanted it. read less

Delicious pizza, addictive garlic knots, fabulous employees and speedy delivery. My absolute first choice when I am craving pizza. Thank... read moreDelicious pizza, addictive garlic knots, fabulous employees and speedy delivery. My absolute first choice when I am craving pizza. Thank you, Donato's...you are the best!! read less

Delicious food

This restaurant has been the best I have eaten from in the Woodside area, I mean from all angles it... read moreThis restaurant has been the best I have eaten from in the Woodside area, I mean from all angles it is the best; food, prices, portion and customer service is just a box of greatness. The manager Pablo came by every table making sure that everyone was ok. Thank you so much for your great services to our community! read less

This place is an overall slamdunk! The food is absolutely amazing, the owner and his family are extremely kind and... read moreThis place is an overall slamdunk! The food is absolutely amazing, the owner and his family are extremely kind and attentive and the food is completely amazing. I have had pizza and lunch type food as well as amazing entrées for dinner and Delicious salads. There is nothing served here that would  disappoint. Right now they even have a few tables outside for outside dining as well. You have to check this place out. You will not be disappointed! read less

Another great night last night sitting outdoors.
Great service and a walnut salad, a calamari salad 5 stars. 2 great fusilli... read moreAnother great night last night sitting outdoors.
Great service and a walnut salad, a calamari salad 5 stars. 2 great fusilli dishes with eggplant , mushrooms , oil garlic ,simply does not get better in a neighborhood restaurant . read less

The best food in town

I decided to order from here from seamless tonight for dinner. The shrimp oreganata tasted so good. I will definitely... read moreI decided to order from here from seamless tonight for dinner. The shrimp oreganata tasted so good. I will definitely order from here again. I tried my boyfriends penne ala vodka and the sauce was great. I rate the vodka sauce a 10 !!!!! I even stole some bites from his dish before i gave it to him because it was that good !!!! Haha I'll be back for sure. read less

Fresh and delicious! I'm always happy with the freshness, quality ingredients and friendly people there. Can't say a bad thing.

Nothing bad to say Love this place. Food is great super fast service even when busy excellent service All employees super friendly from the... read moreLove this place. Food is great super fast service even when busy excellent service All employees super friendly from the cashier to waitress to bus boy Good for breakfast lunch and dinner. read less

I HIGHLY recommend this placed based on the great quality of food/taste, great service and atmosphere.
I have been coming... read moreI HIGHLY recommend this placed based on the great quality of food/taste, great service and atmosphere.
I have been coming here for many years with my family and it never disappoints. The waiters are always attentive and courteous; they make you feel at home. Needless to say that the owners are always around and always making sure you are taken care of.
I highly recommend the seafood combination dish; it taste great and is a generous size. It reminds me of a restaurant I had seafood pasta in Venice, but better! read less

Great Variety of Gluten-free Food Our family of four, all gluten-intolerant, found this restaurant while visiting family in the area. Three of us had breakfast;... read moreOur family of four, all gluten-intolerant, found this restaurant while visiting family in the area. Three of us had breakfast; one had lunch. The french fries have a separate frier; they offer gf french toast and gf pancakes, gf buns, gf bacon, gf sausage. Everything was delicious, and the service was extremely friendly. Couldn't be happier - highly recommend!! read less

Great food made fresh ! Excellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for... read moreExcellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for dinner! all fresh and homemade tasting, from breakfast to dinner they serve it all fresh hot and a smile all at a reasonable price! read less

I always order delivery and the food is delicious, hot and arrives at a reasonable time. Would recommend

Excellent Food and Service Marian and Andy run a wonderful Greek diner, with delicious food and great service. The servers and always polite and... read moreMarian and Andy run a wonderful Greek diner, with delicious food and great service. The servers and always polite and friendly. The restaurant and especially the bathrooms are always clean. I come here often either alone or with friends and have never had a disappointing meal. I also recently attended a surprise birthday party catered by Greek Island Diner and the food was amazing! There was a make-your-own Greek salad bar with all the fixings, and a variety of hot and cold foods. Truly delicious and plentiful! Consider them for your next catered party! read less

Well first of all I've been living around this place for a long time I never got a chance to... read moreWell first of all I've been living around this place for a long time I never got a chance to go inside and eat I highly recommend it ordered the veal cutlet Parmesan dinner with fettuccine Alfredo and enjoy I actually loved pizzas great the atmosphere is great service was great thanks Donato's read less

Excellent Food And Service We recently got takeout for five people and our order was promptly filled in twenty minutes. The food was delicious... read moreWe recently got takeout for five people and our order was promptly filled in twenty minutes. The food was delicious and the portions were large. read less

Amazing pizza, especially the classic : margarita !
We had great time, Miguel the waiter gave good advices, and the... read moreAmazing pizza, especially the classic : margarita !
We had great time, Miguel the waiter gave good advices, and the wine suggested really good too (not always easy to find).
I have orderd a few times since and always good! read less

Perfect and cconvenient We had lunch and 2 breakfasts here while on our "girls getaway". The menu is huge and everything that everyone... read moreWe had lunch and 2 breakfasts here while on our "girls getaway". The menu is huge and everything that everyone got was excellent (salads, paninis, omelets, etc). read less

Cute, no frills, pizza place with restaurant seating. The best penne alla vodka in Queens. The service is always consistent... read moreCute, no frills, pizza place with restaurant seating. The best penne alla vodka in Queens. The service is always consistent and sweet. Mike always remembers my order even when its been months since ive been there. read less

Delightfully anachronistic. Solid neighborhood joint with old school Italian food (think lasagna, pizza, chicken marsala etc). No pretension, good service,... read moreDelightfully anachronistic. Solid neighborhood joint with old school Italian food (think lasagna, pizza, chicken marsala etc). No pretension, good service, family friendly. read less

My husband and I have ordered delivery from Donato's multiple times and really enjoyed it but tonight we went in... read moreMy husband and I have ordered delivery from Donato's multiple times and really enjoyed it but tonight we went in for dinner and the service and pizza and Greek salad were fantastic. read less

Not sure why the photos uploaded by the business owner are wrong? Don't be fooled though. This place is amazing... read moreNot sure why the photos uploaded by the business owner are wrong? Don't be fooled though. This place is amazing and is definitely not a chain!! They have the most amazing alfredo, hands down the best I've had. And their marinara is soooo flavorful, perfect place for a quick slice or if you want pasta. Classic. read less